Grading Buffalo Nickels: A Detailed Guide

Buffalo nickels, also known as Indian Head nickels, are a popular coin among collectors. Issued from 1913 to 1938, these coins feature a Native American on one side and a buffalo on the other. Understanding how these coins are graded can greatly influence their value.

The Basics of Coin Grading

Coin grading involves assessing the condition of a coin. It’s a crucial skill for determining the worth of coins like the buffalo nickel. The Sheldon Scale is the most commonly used system, ranging from 1 to 70, with 70 being a perfect coin. Grading factors include strike quality, surface preservation, luster, and eye appeal.

Understanding the Grades

Grading buffalo nickels starts with understanding their luster. Coin luster refers to the way light reflects off a coin’s surface. Untouched mint luster is highly desirable and often indicates a well-preserved buffalo nickel. Another important factor is the surface condition, which includes any marks, scratches, or wear that the coin may have suffered.

• Good (G-4): Heavy wear with outlines of the design visible.
• Very Good (VG-8): Design worn but complete with clear major details.
• Fine (F-12): Moderate wear, even details.
• Very Fine (VF-20): Moderate wear with most details present.
• Extremely Fine (EF-40): Light wear on high points.
• About Uncirculated (AU-50): Traces of wear on high points but mostly mint luster.
• Mint State (MS-60 to MS-70): No wear, original luster, sharp details.

As coins transition from one grading category to another, the criteria become more nuanced. For a nickel to be considered Mint State, any imperfections must be minor and not detract from the coin’s overall appeal.

Key Areas to Examine

When grading buffalo nickels, focus first on high points of the design. These areas, like the buffalo’s shoulder and hip, show wear earliest. The date is also crucial. Many buffalo nickels suffer from date wear due to design issues. A clear date significantly impacts the coin’s value.

Common Issues in Buffalo Nickels

Due to their age and circulation, buffalo nickels often have specific issues. Date wear is prevalent, as noted, because high reliefs caused the date to wear quickly. One way to counteract this is the use of Restoration, but these practices affect value. Acid-treated coins or coins with tampered surfaces are less valuable to serious collectors.

Professional Grading Services

For collectors uncertain about their ability to grade coins accurately, professional grading services like NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) and PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) offer reliable evaluations. These services authenticate and grade coins, providing additional market trustworthiness and often increasing a coin’s market value.

Impact of Rarity and Demand

The rarity of certain dates and mint marks can affect the grading process and pricing. The 1913 Type 1 and Type 2 nickels, for example, have different designs, with Type 2 being more common. Key dates like the 1918/7-D and the 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo are much sought after. Collectors often focus on these issues, impacting demand and value.

Tools for Grading

A magnifying glass or loupe is essential for examining details and identifying wear. Lighting is another critical factor—natural light is preferred for a realistic view of the coin’s condition. Handling should be minimal, ideally wearing gloves to avoid oils and dirt transfer.

The Role of Documentation

Keeping records of each coin’s acquisition, condition, and price is crucial, especially for building and maintaining a collection. Many collectors opt for software and databases to track inventory. Documentation also helps should you decide to sell or consign the collection.

Common Mistakes in Grading

Over-grading is a common error among novices, where the novice perceives the coin as in better condition than it is. Bias can also alter perceived grading, either overestimating due to personal biases or undervaluing due to market pressures. Learning to separate emotion and market value is critical for accurate grading.

Enhancing Skills Over Time

Like any other skill, grading coins improves with experience. Attending coin shows and joining collector communities can provide insights and practical experience. Comparing your graded coins with professionally graded examples can also allay uncertainty and improve accuracy over time.

Resources for Further Learning

The American Numismatic Association offers certification programs for professional grading. Books and online resources are also invaluable. Engaging with forums and online groups like CoinCommunity also provide communal wisdom and advice from those with more experience.

The journey of understanding and grading buffalo nickels requires time, patience, and practice. Yet, every invested moment adds depth and enjoyment to the hobby of collecting these historical pieces.

“`